Midtown East, Manhattan, New York
Sushi Sho
Keiji Nakazawa's Edomae counter near the Public Library became the first sushi room in New York to reach three stars since Masa.
FlightLogic expert score: 9.6/10 · ££££ · Japanese , Sushi
Quick answer
Is Sushi Sho worth visiting? FlightLogic assigns an expert score of 9.6/10 based on editorial research. The 4.8/5 star figure is an editorial composite for guide comparison — not a verified consumer aggregate. It has 3 Michelin stars. Best for milestone celebrations, serious sushi devotees, pre-theater splurges near bryant park.
About Sushi Sho
Sushi Sho earned its third MICHELIN star at the November 2025 Northeast Cities ceremony, promoted from two, and became the first sushi restaurant in New York to reach the top rank since Masa. Chef Keiji Nakazawa works a twelve-seat hinoki counter blocks from the New York Public Library, aging his own tuna and cutting rice temperature by the piece rather than by the batch. The room does one thing — a single omakase, no menu, no substitutions — and does it with a rigor that reads as calm rather than tense. Nothing here is loud; the discipline is the point.
Menu highlights
Editorial rating breakdown
Published reviews
Sorted by date (newest first). We do not reorder by rating or “helpfulness”. Review integrity policy
- 5.0Editorial sample
Watched Nakazawa adjust the rice temperature between two pieces of the same fish and could taste the difference. This is craft with no wasted motion.
Response from Sushi Sho
Thank you, Daniel — precision is the whole point of the counter. We hope to see you again soon.
- 5.0Editorial sample
Twelve seats, total silence except the hinoki block. The tamago at the end nearly undid me — dense, barely sweet, warm.
Submit a verified dining review
Consumer reviews require on-site geolocation verification or transaction proof before publication. See our review integrity policy.
How far in advance should I book Sushi Sho?
Reservations open 30 days out and the twelve-seat counter fills within hours, especially for Friday and Saturday seatings — book the moment the window opens.
Is there a set menu, or can I request specific pieces?
The counter runs a single nightly omakase built around that day's fish; substitutions are not offered, though allergies are accommodated with advance notice.
More in New York
★★ Michelin
Aquavit
Scandinavian · Nordic
Expert 9.2/10
A glass-walled Midtown atrium where Emma Bengtsson has spent a decade refining Nordic fine dining into something quietly, precisely her own.
Aska
Scandinavian · Foraged
Expert 9.5/10
A converted Williamsburg warehouse where fermentation and fire do the talking for a two-Michelin-starred Scandinavian tasting menu.